Naija Talk community

Ghana Lotto Results, F-t-a Satellite Technology, Sport forcast, ICT forum.
 
HomeHOMEFAQSearchMemberlistRegisterUsergroupsLog in
Share | 
 

 MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
AuthorMessage
eddyvic
Expert
Expert


Sex : male
Posts : 4482
Location : Abk

PostSubject: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 14:47

A Federal High Court in Lagos has
fixed May 21, 2015 to rule on an
application filed in objection to the
suit seeking to restrain Multichoice
Nigeria Limited from increasing
subscription fees on the Digital
Satellite television being operated
by it.
Two Lagos-based legal
practitioners, Osasuyi Adebayo and
Oluyinka Oyeniji, had filed the class
action on behalf of themselves and
all other DStv subscribers across
the country.
The plaintiffs were seeking an
order of the court restraining
MultiChoice from implementing the
20 per cent increment on DStv
subscription rate which began on
April 1, 2015.
They also want the court to compel
the National Broadcasting
Commission to regulate the
activities of MultiChoice so as to
prevent what they described as
arbitrary increment in subscription
rates.
They specifically want an
implementation of the pay-per-
view scheme in Nigeria, whereby
subscribers would only pay for
programmes they watched, as is
being done in other parts of the
world where MultiChoice operates.
But MultiChoice, through its lawyer,
Mr. Moyosore Onigbanjo (SAN), filed
a preliminary objection, urging the
court to decline jurisdiction and
discountenance the reliefs being
sought by the plaintiffs.
Canvassing argument at the
Tuesday’s proceeding, Onigbanjo
maintained that the plaintiffs had
no cause of action, adding that a
court did not have the power to
regulate the price of services that a
business was offering to its
customers.
He pointed the attention of the
court to MultiChoice’s conditions or
terms of agreement, especially
clauses 40 and 41 stating that
“Multichoice Nigeria may, from
time to time, change the fees
payable to Multichoice Nigeria for
the Multichoice Service by way of
general amendment.”
Onigbanjo said, “My Lord, the
country, Nigeria operates a free
market economy; neither the
government nor the court can
regulate prices. How do you now
say, for instance, that one bread is
more expensive than the other and
then ask the court to order the
baker of the more expensive bread
to go out of the market?”
Onigbanjo argued further that
there was no existing law in
Nigeria empowering the NBC to
regulate the prices of services that
satellite television operators in the
country were offering to their
customers.
“The NBC Act does not say that any
satellite television operators in the
country cannot increase their
prices.
“I therefore humbly ask that the
plaintiffs’ suit be struck out for
being grossly unmeritorious. We
will not be asking for cost because
they are our subscribers,”
Onigbanjo submitted.
Justice C.J. Aneke adjourned till May
21 to rule on the objection.
Earlier at the proceeding, counsel
for the plaintiffs, Yemi Salma, had
reminded the court that there was
a pending application for committal
filed against the Managing Director
and the Public Relations Officer of
Multichoice, Mr. John Ugbe and
Caroline Oghuma respectively.
Salma said the said committal
application asking the court to jail
Ugbe and Oghuma for allegedly
disobeying an order of the court
should be taken first before any
other thing on Tuesday.
Aneke had on April 2, 2015 made an
interim order restraining
MultiChoice from implementing the
20 per cent increment in
subscription rate on DStv, pending
the determination of the suit; but
the plaintiffs alleged that the order
was shunned.
“My Lord, the application for
contempt must be taken first. My
Lord, this position has been
severally adopted by the court,
even by the Court of Appeal,” Salma
said.
But in opposition, Onigbanjo said
the jurisdiction of the court had
been challenged and that that had
to be settled first before the court
could even make any order.
Besides, he reminded the court
that the matter was specifically
adjourned for the hearing of his
client’s preliminary objection,
arguing that the court did not have
the power to overrule itself.
He argued, “My Lord, a court
without jurisdiction that goes on to
act, does whatever it does in
futility. If a court does not have
jurisdiction, where does the power
for committal come from?”
Aneke upheld Onigbanjo’s
submission and therefore heard
MultiChoice’s premilinary objection
ahead of the application for
committal.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
The author of this message was banned from the forum - See the message
isaac311
Enthusiast
Enthusiast


Sex : Male
Posts : 1920
Location : nairobi

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 19:56

hmmm.. their prices are quite high for sure.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
irondehero42
Senior
Senior


Sex : male
Posts : 947

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 21:54

Will continue to use dogs
Back to top Go down
View user profile
smile2012
Ultimate
Ultimate


Sex : male
Posts : 20750
Location : lag

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 22:19

Pay per view....sikena
Back to top Go down
View user profile
irondehero42
Senior
Senior


Sex : male
Posts : 947

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 22:44

Sikena paaa
Back to top Go down
View user profile
delafirst
Leader
Leader


Sex : mele
Posts : 5359
Location : Accra

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 23:10

@shukman2000 wrote:
look at dis stellars
Back to top Go down
View user profile
delafirst
Leader
Leader


Sex : mele
Posts : 5359
Location : Accra

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-05, 23:12

@shukman2000 wrote:
look at dis stellars
Lol
Back to top Go down
View user profile
unikazzy
Novice
Novice


Sex : male
Posts : 95

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-06, 04:55

They hold their side na.....no be by force
Back to top Go down
View user profile
smile2012
Ultimate
Ultimate


Sex : male
Posts : 20750
Location : lag

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-06, 07:19

Are u serious?
Back to top Go down
View user profile
delafirst
Leader
Leader


Sex : mele
Posts : 5359
Location : Accra

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-06, 08:27

Hmmm...
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Twogoods
Expert
Expert


Sex : Male
Posts : 4989
Location : Africa Best Lotto Forecaster. EDO BENIN CITY

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-06, 12:05

U really no it
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.fb.com/inforNaij
irondehero42
Senior
Senior


Sex : male
Posts : 947

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-06, 21:59

Thieves
Back to top Go down
View user profile
delafirst
Leader
Leader


Sex : mele
Posts : 5359
Location : Accra

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-06, 22:30

hahaha,
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Twogoods
Expert
Expert


Sex : Male
Posts : 4989
Location : Africa Best Lotto Forecaster. EDO BENIN CITY

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 04:56

Dey want to frustrate Nigeria's the more
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.fb.com/inforNaij
eddyvic
Expert
Expert


Sex : male
Posts : 4482
Location : Abk

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 05:39

They can not bro, we are wise
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Twogoods
Expert
Expert


Sex : Male
Posts : 4989
Location : Africa Best Lotto Forecaster. EDO BENIN CITY

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 05:54

@eddyvic wrote:
They can not bro, we are wise
i pray so
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.fb.com/inforNaij
xedyl
Senior
Senior


Sex : Male
Posts : 798
Location : mosho

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 06:58

No be by force to use dstv
Back to top Go down
View user profile
delafirst
Leader
Leader


Sex : mele
Posts : 5359
Location : Accra

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 08:25

True ooo
Back to top Go down
View user profile
eddyvic
Expert
Expert


Sex : male
Posts : 4482
Location : Abk

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 09:58

@xedyl wrote:
No be by force to use dstv
Nah so
Back to top Go down
View user profile
20manlotto
Enthusiast
Enthusiast


Sex : male
Posts : 1817

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 14:07

DSTV shah
Back to top Go down
View user profile
tundew84
Novice
Novice


Sex : Male
Posts : 49
Location : Kogi

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 14:36

dstv are thieves they knew the pay per view will reduce there income useless country with useless leaders taking all our beloved right
Back to top Go down
View user profile
20manlotto
Enthusiast
Enthusiast


Sex : male
Posts : 1817

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 20:06

@tundew84 wrote:
dstv are thieves they knew the pay per view will reduce there income useless country with useless leaders taking all our beloved right
Trul talk
Back to top Go down
View user profile
delafirst
Leader
Leader


Sex : mele
Posts : 5359
Location : Accra

PostSubject: Re: MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription   2015-05-07, 21:20

Hmmm, is not easy ooo...
Back to top Go down
View user profile
 
MultiChoice objects to reduction in DStv subscription
View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Naija Talk community :: General :: News-
Jump to: